How to Fix Poor Tokenomics: A Creator's Guide to Better Token Design
Poor tokenomics is the leading cause of token failure, often stemming from rushed launches and misaligned incentives. This guide provides concrete steps to identify and fix common tokenomic flaws, from supply inflation to weak utility. Building on better practices can increase holder confidence and project longevity.
Try It NowKey Benefits
The Problem
Traditional solutions are complex, time-consuming, and often require technical expertise.
The Solution
Spawned provides an AI-powered platform that makes building fast, simple, and accessible to everyone.
What Makes Tokenomics 'Poor'?
Before you can fix the problem, you need to diagnose it correctly.
Poor tokenomics refers to a token's economic design that creates negative pressure on its price, disincentivizes holding, or fails to align the project's long-term goals with its supporters. It's not just about a low price; it's about a flawed system.
Common red flags include a total supply that's too large or unpredictable (like adding a 2% daily inflation), a majority of tokens held by the team with no lock-up, or a token that serves no purpose other than speculation. When a token has no clear utility or revenue mechanism—like not being used to pay for services within its own ecosystem—it becomes a meme coin with an expiration date. Projects that launch purely for a quick profit often exhibit these traits, leading to rapid abandonment.
The 5 Most Common Tokenomics Mistakes (And How to Fix Them)
Most token failures can be traced back to a handful of critical errors. Addressing these systematically can rescue a struggling project or set a new one on the right path.
1. Hyper-Inflationary Supply:
- Mistake: An unlimited or poorly scheduled token emission that constantly dilutes holders. Example: A 10% monthly unlock for 'marketing' with no cap.
- Fix: Implement a fixed, transparent emission schedule. Lock team and advisor tokens for a minimum period (e.g., 1-2 years with monthly vesting). Consider a deflationary mechanism like token burns from revenue.
2. Concentrated & Unlocked Distribution:
- Mistake: The team or early investors control 40%+ of supply with the ability to sell immediately at launch.
- Fix: Enforce vesting schedules for all insiders. Distribute tokens more widely through Learn about airdrops or fair launch mechanisms. Aim for no single wallet to hold more than 5-10% at launch.
3. The 'Utility' Token with No Utility:
- Mistake: The token's only use case is to be traded. It grants no special access, governance rights, or discounted fees.
- Fix: Integrate the token into your product. Use it for paying platform fees, voting on proposals, or unlocking premium features. Make it essential to the user experience.
4. No Clear Revenue Model:
- Mistake: The project generates no income, so there is no capital to fund development, marketing, or token buybacks.
- Fix: Build a sustainable fee model. For a launchpad, this could be a 1% fee on successful launches. Direct a portion (e.g., 50%) of this revenue to a treasury for buybacks or staking rewards.
5. Misaligned Incentives:
- Mistake: The economic model rewards short-term trading over long-term holding.
- Fix: Implement holder rewards. For example, Spawned's model directs 0.30% of every trade automatically to existing token holders, creating a continuous incentive to hold.
How a Better Launch Model Prevents Poor Tokenomics
The right launch environment sets the foundation for long-term success.
Many tokenomic flaws are baked in at launch. Choosing a launchpad that enforces better practices can prevent problems before they start. Here's how a platform like Spawned is structured to support sustainable tokenomics versus a basic launcher.
| Feature | Typical Basic Launcher (e.g., pump.fun) | Spawned's Integrated Model |
|---|---|---|
| Holder Incentives | None. No ongoing reward for holding. | 0.30% of every trade is automatically distributed to holders, building loyalty. |
| Project Revenue | Often 0% after launch. No sustainable funding. | 0.30% fee per trade for creators, plus 1% perpetual fee post-graduation via Token-2022. |
| Lock-up & Vesting | Usually manual, optional, and off-platform. | Encouraged and can be facilitated through smart contract standards at launch. |
| Post-Launch Support | Minimal. Project is on its own after the initial raise. | Built-in path to graduation with continued fee structure, aiding long-term planning. |
| Cost to Start | Low or no upfront cost. | 0.1 SOL launch fee includes an AI website builder, saving $29-99/month on external tools. |
The key difference is sustainability. Spawned's built-in 0.30% holder reward and creator revenue create a circular economy from day one, discouraging pump-and-dump behavior and funding ongoing development.
A 4-Step Process to Redesign Your Tokenomics
If your token is already live and struggling, a thoughtful redesign (or 'v2') can rebuild trust. This requires clear communication and a fair migration plan.
Step 1: Transparent Diagnosis & Communication Publicly audit your current tokenomics. Write a report acknowledging specific flaws (e.g., 'Our emission schedule is too aggressive, diluting holders by 5% monthly'). Honesty builds credibility.
Step 2: Design the V2 Model Using the fixes above, draft new tokenomics. Key decisions:
- New Total Supply: Often a reduction via a migration ratio (e.g., 1000:1).
- New Distribution: Allocate for liquidity, community rewards, and a vested treasury.
- New Utility: Define at least one core, actionable use case.
Step 3: Create a Fair Migration Plan Allow all current holders to swap to V2 at a fixed ratio over a set period (e.g., 30 days). Snapshot holdings at a specific block. Consider bonus tiers for long-term holders.
Step 4: Launch & Integrate Deploy the new token. Immediately lock liquidity (e.g., using Meteora or Orca Whirlpools). Integrate the token's new utility into your product or website. Announce the start of the new revenue and reward distributions.
Concrete Examples of Strong Token Utility
Move from abstract promises to tangible functions.
A token needs a job. Here are specific, implementable utilities that go beyond 'governance' (which often has low participation).
- Fee Payment & Discount: Use your token as the primary currency for your service. Offer a 25% discount when fees are paid with the native token versus SOL or USDC. This creates constant buy pressure.
- Revenue Share & Buybacks: Allocate a fixed percentage of your project's revenue (e.g., 50% of the 0.30% trade fee) to a smart contract that automatically buys tokens from the market and burns them or distributes them to stakers.
- Access & Gating: Require a minimum token balance to access certain features. For a gaming token, this could be early beta access, exclusive in-game items, or special tournaments. See how to create a gaming token on Solana for more context.
- Staking for Service Tiers: Allow users to stake tokens to unlock higher service tiers. For example, stake 10,000 tokens to get a 'Pro' launchpad tier with a lower minting fee or featured placement.
- Collateral in Your Ecosystem: If your project involves lending or insurance, allow your native token to be used as collateral (with a conservative LTV ratio). This ties the token's health directly to the ecosystem's usage.
Build Tokenomics That Last
Fixing poor tokenomics is an investment in your project's future. It transforms your token from a speculative asset into the foundational economic layer of your community.
Ready to launch a token with sustainable economics from the start? Spawned is built to support creators who think long-term. With automatic 0.30% holder rewards, a clear creator revenue stream, and an integrated AI website builder, your project launches with stronger fundamentals.
Launch Your Token on Spawned - Start for 0.1 SOL.
For deeper research, compare how different chains approach token creation.
Related Topics
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, but it requires careful planning and transparent communication. The most common method is a 'V2 migration,' where you create a new, improved token contract and allow existing holders to swap their old tokens for new ones at a predetermined ratio. This is a significant event that must be handled fairly to maintain community trust. Clearly explain the flaws in V1 and the concrete benefits of V2.
Creating a token with no purpose other than speculation. If the token isn't needed to use, benefit from, or govern the underlying project, it has no fundamental demand driver. Its price will be purely based on hype, which inevitably fades. Always design utility first, token second.
They directly align incentives. A static token offers no benefit for holding during price dips, encouraging sells. An automatic reward share creates a yield, similar to a dividend. This incentivizes holders to keep their tokens staked or in their wallet, reducing sell pressure during volatility and building a more stable, long-term holder base.
Not inherently, but it's often mismanaged. A supply of 1 billion tokens isn't problematic if the price per token is proportionally low and the emission schedule is controlled. The problem arises when the supply is massively inflationary or when a large, unlocked portion is held by a few wallets that can dump on the market. Transparency and controlled vesting are more important than the raw number.
A launchpad sets the initial conditions. A basic launchpad simply facilitates the token creation and initial liquidity. An advanced launchpad, like Spawned, can embed sustainable economic features into the launch itself—such as automatic holder rewards and a clear fee structure for the creator. This builds better fundamentals from block one, rather than leaving the creator to add them later.
Typically 10-20% of the total supply is considered standard for early contributors and the treasury. This allocation must be subject to a long vesting period—at least 1 year, often 2-4 years with a cliff (e.g., nothing for 6 months, then monthly vesting). This proves the team is committed to the project's long-term success, not a quick exit.
While not strictly required for the technical design, legal consultation is highly recommended, especially if you have a global audience. Regulations around securities vary by country. A lawyer can help structure your token's utility and sales to comply with relevant laws, which is a critical part of sustainable project design.
Ready to get started?
Join thousands of users who are already building with Spawned. Start your project today - no credit card required.